Arizona Voters Take Stand against Illegal Immigration
November 6th, 2008Arizona Voters Take Stand against Illegal Immigration
Arizona voters went to the polls on Election Day and soundly rejected Proposition 202, a ballot initiative that would have made it virtually impossible for state officials to enforce state laws against employers who hire illegal aliens. With almost all Arizona precincts reporting, approximately 60% of Arizona voters have rebuffed the initiative. (CNN Election Center)
Misleadingly titled the Stop Illegal Hiring Act, Proposition 202 would have rendered current law meaningless by changing the requirement that Arizona employers use E-Verify to gain a presumption that they did not intentionally hire an illegal alien. If the initiative would have passed, this provision would have been changed to grant an employer a “non-rebuttable presumption of innocence” as long as the employer took the minimal steps of filing federal I-9 paperwork - a requirement already mandated by federal law. This non-rebuttable presumption would have, in essence, prevented officials from prosecuting employers who hired illegal aliens, as long as they fulfilled the minimal requirement of filing I-9 paperwork.
Proposition 202 was backed by some of the state’s largest business owners who formed the group Wake Up, Arizona - a coalition including owners of car washes, homebuilders, prominent Republicans, and fast food franchisees Mac Macgruder and Jason LaVecke. The Arizona Republic reported the day after the election that business groups supporting Proposition 202 had proposed the initiative, raised nearly $900,000 in support of the measure, and launched an advertising campaign two weeks prior to the election. Opponents of Proposition 202, on the other hand, spent only $15,000. (The Arizona Republic, November 5, 2008)
Exit polling indicated that a wide range of Arizonians opposed Proposition 202. According to CNN, men and women both opposed the measure at a rate of about 60%. Proposition 202 was also evenly rejected by Arizona voters without regard to political ideology, religious background, economic status, educational level, and race; in fact, 60% of whites and 56% of Latinos opposed the initiative. (CNN Exit Polling)
Speaking to the misleading title of the initiative and the massive special interest-backed campaign that had deceptively touted Proposition 202 as a crackdown on illegal aliens, State Representative Russell Pearce expressed his pleasure with Arizona voters: “We’ve got a great, smart electorate here in Arizona.” (Id.)
